Free the Obamacare 15 Million…They’re not ‘losing’ insurance; they just won’t be forced to get policies they don’t want.

Loading

Doug Badger:

The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) today warned lawmakers that 15 million people will lose medical coverage next year if the Senate GOP’s health-care bill becomes law.

That’s not quite accurate. CBO doesn’t believe that millions will “lose” their insurance in 2018. Instead, the agency thinks that millions will happily cancel their coverage — even those who get it for free. The reason: The Senate bill would repeal the Obamacare tax penalty on the uninsured, known as the individual mandate.

Supporters of Obamacare proclaim that the law has reduced the number of people who lack coverage. They’re right. Government surveys show that the number of non-elderly uninsured people fell from 44.3 million in December 2013 (the month before Obamacare took full effect) to 28.2 million at the end of last year. That’s 16 million fewer uninsured people over a period of only three years, a genuine public-policy achievement.

But here’s the catch: If CBO is to be believed, 15 million people didn’t want health coverage in the first place. They enrolled only to keep the IRS off their backs.

In its analysis of the Senate bill, CBO predicts that repealing the tax on the uninsured would next year induce 7 million people to cancel their individual insurance policies, 4 million to drop their job-based coverage, and 4 million others to abandon Medicaid, even though the government provides it free of charge in most cases.

If CBO is right, these 15 million Americans would take immediate advantage of a provision freeing them from the obligation to obtain a product they neither want nor feel they need.

Those 15 million would join a legion of refuseniks who either paid or circumvented Obamacare’s tax on the uninsured. Last January, the IRS commissioner reported to Congress on the number of uninsured people who had paid the tax, obtained a waiver, or refused to tell the government whether they had insurance in 2015. He reported that:

6.2 million uninsured people paid the tax on the uninsured;

12.7 uninsured million people — more than twice as many — obtained exemptions from the penalty;

4.3 million people “didn’t check the box” — they simply refused to tell the IRS whether they had insurance. The government processed their tax forms and sent them their refunds without enforcing the coverage requirement.

That totals 23.2 million Americans who paid, avoided, or ignored the individual mandate. Repealing that mandate would emancipate them from IRS oversight and liberate an additional 15 million people (if you believe CBO) from coverage they’d rather not have.

It’s rare that Congress writes a bill that would please more than 38 million people without inflicting hardship on others (although health-policy theorists infatuated with the individual mandate will grieve its passing). Congress should not squander that opportunity.

The mandate, like the full repeal of Obamacare, is not politically viable. Both the House and Senate bills largely retain the Obamacare subsidies, insurance regulations, exchanges, and Medicaid expansion. The subsidies in those bills are less generous and more convoluted than those in Obamacare, but otherwise are indistinguishable from them.

Read more

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments