Ed Driscoll:
Last night, Glenn Reynolds featured the “Blog Comment of the Day,” which could be found at William A. Jacobson’s Legal Insurrection site:
“Fascinating that a man shouting ‘Allahu akbar’ as he mows down 35 people on an army base isn’t motivated by Islam… but a guy who has the same name as hundreds of others—and says nothing as he fires—is obviously a Tea Party zealot.”
As Glenn replied, “It’s all about the narrative.”
W. Joseph Campbell, the veteran journalist and author ofGetting It Wrong: Ten of the Greatest Misreported Stories in American Journalism, who blogs at his Media Myth Alert Website writes that the MSM is “Slow to learn: Lesson for journos in Brian Ross’ egregious error on ABC.” But they’re only lessons to be learned if the MSM considers itself to be in the reporting business. They do not — they’re in the business of advancing narratives which help advance the right (read: left) politics:
How did Ross — a veteran television reporter whoseABC biography unabashedly declares him “one of the most honored and respected journalists in the country” — come to disseminate “information before it was properly vetted”?
ABC’s apology didn’t say.
It may have been that Ross was excessively eager to be first in reporting a linkage to a conservative political movement. He may have been unable to restrain his ideological inclinations. He may have been misled by a producer.
Whatever the reason, his error on a television program that attracts 4.5 million viewers was inexcusable — and eminently preventable….
The MSM’s response to all of that would be a loud, “So what?” As always, the narrative trumps all. From their point of view, Katrina wasn’t botched; as the New York Times said the previous year when it dismissed Dan Rather’s RatherGate debacle, it was merely “fake but accurate.” The media’s truthiness in Katrina ultimatelyserved a higher purpose, which could be seen in the election results the following year and in 2008.
And so what if Brian Ross is fired from ABC? Vivian Schiller of NPR can fire Juan Williams for a thoughtcrime that he expressly stated he didn’t act upon, recommend Soviet-style psychiatry for him, and bounce back on her feet (or “fail upward,” as Stacy McCain recently put it) as “Chief Digital Officer” at NBC News’ Internet division. If you thought NBC was rather biased now…
I think the Tea Party Jim Holmes of Aurora, Colorado has grounds to sue Brian Ross and ABC news for malicious slander. This is becoming a common occurrence for the MSM and it is high time that innocent wrongly maligned take them to the courts. If journalistic ethics is going to be thrown out the window in the name of sensationalism, then they need to be treated like the tabloid trash they have become.
A short, incomplete history of media tying the Tea Party to tragedies
And, after the slander, the ABC’s retraction didn’t make reference to the Tea Party Jim Holmes, but, rather to “a” Jim Holmes … as in …we didn’t actually ‘pin’ the tail on our Donkey… we missed by miles….we tried and got the wrong guy – “So What?!”
If I were the wrong Jim Holmes I’d be fuming … there was no “Honest Mistake” here, not by any stretch of the imagination… but, so what?!
If you ask me, this type of political shill behavior by the MSM [and it’s base] is really ‘childish’…No wonder ALL the MSM’s rating’s are in the tank …
Nothing to see here….let’s move along…