by JACK DUNPHY
We begin with the obvious, something on which all can agree: It is beyond heartbreaking that 13-year-old Adam Toledo was shot and killed by a Chicago police officer on March 29. The violent death of someone so young, captured on video and broadcast to the world, jars something deep in all of us and impels us to search for ways to protect other children from a similar fate. This unanimity of thought soon dissolves, however, when there is disagreement on solutions and even on the demonstrable facts of Toledo’s death.
On March 29, just before 2:30 a.m., officers from the Chicago Police Department’s 10th District, on the city’s West Side, responded to a radio call generated by the city’s ShotSpotter system, which detects gunshots via acoustic devices and directs police to their source. The officers were dispatched to the corner of 24th Street and Sawyer Avenue, in the Little Village neighborhood, where eight gunshots had been detected.
Two officers drove into an alley off Sawyer south of 23rd Street where they saw Toledo and Ruben Roman, 21, at the rear of 2334 South Sawyer. They were the only two people out and about in an otherwise sleeping neighborhood. Or perhaps we should say the neighborhood was sleeping until the gunshots rang out, a sound to which residents in that and many other neighborhoods on Chicago’s South and West Sides are wearily accustomed.
Seeking to question them about the gunshots, the officers got out of their car and told the pair to stop. Neither of them complied – Roman began walking south in the alley and Toledo took off running in the same direction. The passenger officer, a woman, quickly detained Roman while her partner, identified as Officer Eric Stillman, a six-year veteran of CPD, ran after Toledo toward 24th Street.
The foot pursuit was captured on Stillman’s body camera and, from some distance away, by a security camera facing east toward the alley. All of the videos from the incident have been compiled here, at the Chicago Office of Police Accountability’s website, but the most pertinent portions, including the precipitating radio call, can be seen here. The videos show Toledo ran about 270 feet before stopping adjacent to an opening in a fence lining the west side of the alley just north of 24th Street.
All of what follows was captured on video, and anyone seeking a full understanding of Adam Toledo’s death must come to terms with what happened at this very split-second. Toledo can be seen using his right hand to pull a pistol from a pocket or his waistband and begin to turn toward Stillman. In Graham v. Connor (1989), the U.S. Supreme Court held that the “reasonableness of a particular use of force must be judged from the perspective of a reasonable officer on the scene, rather than with the 20/20 vision of hindsight.” So, viewing the events from this perspective, we have Officer Stillman responding to reported gunshots at 2:30 a.m. and confronting two males in the immediate vicinity. Both of those males refuse to comply with a uniformed police officer’s clearly stated orders to stop, and one of them runs nearly the length of a football field before stopping, pulling a gun from his pocket or waistband, and turning toward Stillman.
Is there a “reasonable officer” anywhere in the country who would not have fired at Toledo under these circumstances?
What we now know, with the benefit of the 20/20 hindsight the Supreme Court has said we cannot use in judging Stillman’s actions, is that in the instant between Toledo’s drawing of the gun and being shot, he tossed the gun through the gap in the fence and was turning empty-handed toward the officer. It was too late. On seeing the gun, Stillman reasonably believed Toledo was preparing to shoot him and fired in self-defense, striking Toledo in the chest. Stillman, other police officers, and rescue personnel made every effort to treat Toledo’s wound but he died at the scene.
As is often the case in police shootings, particularly those conforming to a certain racial calculus, the actual events leading up to Toledo’s death have been subsumed into a media narrative intended to portray the police as coldblooded assassins preying on innocent young men in “communities of color” and as an entity those communities would be better off without. In advancing the narrative, the media emphasize certain aspects of the story while downplaying or ignoring others. Recall the stubborn persistence of the “hands up, don’t shoot” myth that followed the police shooting death of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Mo., in 2014.
The myth being advanced in the Adam Toledo incident is that he was unarmed when he was shot. And in a hair-splittingly literal sense, it is true that he was not holding a gun at the exact moment Officer Stillman shot him, as revealed by the disturbing still image that accompanied this story published April 15 in the Chicago Tribune and in many other outlets. The image was drawn from video shot by Officer Stillman’s body camera, and though the entire video is linked in the Tribune story, the fact that only this inflammatory image was chosen suggests the editors at the Tribune and elsewhere place more emphasis on advancing the narrative than on informing their readers. If they were desirous of producing a balanced story, the image would have been accompanied by one from only a second earlier, which reveals the pistol in Toledo’s right hand.
Presenting both images along with the complete video would have offered their readers a more complete understanding of what occurred. Future reporting on the incident may include such an image but the narrative has already been unleashed, and as we learned in the Michael Brown case, once such a narrative attains sufficient inertia, almost no amount of debunking can restrain it.
During my long career with the Los Angeles Police Department, I was involved in many foot pursuits of armed young men in some of the city’s most violent neighborhoods. I was blessed, as were the young men I chased, that no gunfire resulted on either side. There are things police officers know about these foot chases that the public should better understand before judging Officer Stillman or any other officer in similar circumstances.
First, cops know that armed suspects most often discard their weapons on first perceiving the arrival of the police. The reason for this is simple: better to ditch the gun than get shot or catch a case for holding onto it (you can always get another one later). If an armed suspect doesn’t abandon his gun, the pursuing officer has no choice but to assume the suspect intends to use it against him, and any reasonable officer will respond accordingly at the first indication of such intent. Sadly for Toledo, perhaps due to his youth and inexperience, he acted in such a way that his movements were interpreted as preparation to fire rather than discard the gun he carried.
And what of Ruben Roman, the man who was with Toledo and who is believed to be the one who fired the gunshots detected by the ShotSpotter system? Evidence suggests both Roman and Toledo were members of the Latin Kings, the dominant street gang in Little Village. It is common for older gang members to direct juveniles to carry weapons for the simple fact that they face less punishment if caught with one. This explains why Toledo ran from the police while Roman merely walked – he was confident that Toledo, even if arrested with the gun, would never tell the police it was Roman who had handed it to him moments earlier.
Most people are unaware of the principle of the “kill zone” of a weapon. The kill zone is the radius in which, unless a person has their weapon already drawn and are instantly prepared and able to fire, the other guy is certain to be able to deploy their weapon BEFORE the person can draw and fire. For a knife, the kill zone is 7 yards – 21 feet. Experiments have proven conclusively that if a potential assailant has a knife in their hand and are within 21 feet of you and you HAVE NOT ALREADY drawn your sidearm, then they can cross that distance AND STAB YOU a full HALF SECOND before you can draw your weapon and bring it to bear.
The kill zone for a pistol is much, Much, MUCH greater than 21 feet. Officer Stillman was WELL within the kill zone for young Tolido (AKA Lil Homicide – wonder how he acquired that moniker?) as he approached in a situation where firearms were KNOWN TO HAVE BEEN INVOLVED! Stillman KNEW he was within the kill zone for a firearm and KNEW he would have at best a split second to react. When he saw the weapon in young Tolido’s hand he did the rational, human thing and fired at what could only be perceived as a mortal threat.
One final observation: As in EVERY OTHER INCIDENT which has been used to inflame people’s sensibilities and portray the police as racist murderers, it was the alleged victims who had control of.the situation. Had they complied with law enforcement, one and all they might well be alive TO. THIS. DAY!The iron law of unintended consequences can be a stone cold bitch sometimes.
Let’s see… I’m sure the leftist argument will be, “Being out at 2:30am shouldn’t be a death sentence!” Or, “Running from police shouldn’t be a death sentence!” Or perhaps even, “Hanging out with a gang thug and firing guns at 2:30am shouldn’t be a death sentence!” And, indeed it shouldn’t. But combining all those, along with the anti-police hatred generated by the left IS, in most cases, an absolute death sentence.
You can even see the pistol had been fired until empty; the slide is locked back indicating an empty magazine. Perhaps the punk emptied the magazine by ejecting all the rounds, for, you know, SAFETY concerns, but I doubt it.
Were they concerned with public safety, the media could be turning down the temperature on this tragic incident (tragic in that the officer is forever consumed with guilt now) but, instead, they intentionally suppress critical details with the purpose of inciting racial division, hatred and more violence.
And to all the “common sense gun control” idiots out there, HERE is your problem. Irresponsible punks who can easily acquire a gun and, because their sub-culture promotes being a punk thug, they abuse the weapon. In addition, the left gives a pass to thugs of certain races that commit minor or major acts of violence, expecting a stern talking to will counteract all their gang buddies praising them for getting away with thuggery.
The reason these are mostly black kids that wind up on the wrong side of a bullet is that culture Hollywood, the music industry and liberal politicians cultivate. The only racism involved is THEIRS.