Subscribe
Notify of
143 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

The cooked data they are releasing is just fiction without the raw data and revelation of their methods. They say they do not even know what stations were in the dataset. There is no record existing explaining how they arrived at the current dataset. That makes it so much garbage. It is worthless because it cannot be checked. This is NOT science. A scientist reveals everything and dares you to break it. This is a scam.

It’s not “bunk”. it’s outright fraud. Global Warming has been the “holy ark” argument that radical leftists have been relying on to force everyone to accept their political agenda. With their end goals finally in reach, they and their MSM cronies are not going to let the general public know about the fraud until it is too late. They are now ignoring the fact that the genii is out of the bottle, as the truth has come out) They are also not now considering the aftermath of their propaganda, but are tring to do damage control for as long as they can. When the public understands that they have been scammed, as the scientist “deniers, conservatives, and others have been trying to tell them, there is going to be a lot of pissed off sheep.

The “climate change” Emperor has no clothes. This now known fact will destroy the trust the people have given every green spouting politician and MSM outlet, and the public will know them for the charlatans that they are. Then the people will wonder “What else have they lied to us about?”

Anyone care to bet how the 2010 elections will swing?

I edited and pasted onto Word and I get 290 pages.

I think this Rajendra Packauri character or his twin brother panhandles on an exit ramp of Interstate 10.

@Skookum: Good one! He sure doesn’t look like the kind of guy I would trust to tell me I have to pay twice as much for electricity so he and his friends can spend the money.

The “botch after botch” comment refers to the input files that the code has to deal with because that is just how the input files are. There is nothing necessarily wrong with having files in different formats, but it is annoying to handle the special cases. It is analogous to having to handle incoming dates in 2009-12-01 format or 12/01/09 format, and it does not imply any shortcoming of the program itself.

@ John Binsel

I find it hard to believe that you went through the effort to post some weak-assed, “new-speak” definition for the word “botch”, and at the same time ignore every other quote.

In the word popular with my teenagers: “Really?”

Could you use your secret decoder ring to decipher these for us too?

“As far as I can see, this renders the (weather) station counts totally meaningless.” (57)

– “COBAR AIRPORT AWS (data from an Australian weather station) cannot start in 1962, it didn’t open until 1993!” (71)

– “What the hell is supposed to happen here? Oh yeah — there is no ’supposed,’ I can make it up. So I have : – )” (98)

– “You can’t imagine what this has cost me — to actually allow the operator to assign false WMO (World Meteorological Organization) codes!! But what else is there in such situations? Especially when dealing with a ‘Master’ database of dubious provenance …” (98)

– “So with a somewhat cynical shrug, I added the nuclear option — to match every WMO possible, and turn the rest into new stations … In other words what CRU usually do. It will allow bad databases to pass unnoticed, and good databases to become bad …” (98-9)

Pffft.

PV, I am in serious need of a decoder ring, do you have a line on them?

Bindel is just following the time honored cherry picking tradition of finding one minor point to nit pick and trying to subliminally conflate that to the whole.

It’s not going to work.

@Skooks

As a matter of fact, they’re having a sale this week only.

Dial: 1-800-L.I.B.-E.R.A.L.

(Thanks for the mail! Response soon)

PV, I laughed so hard my dog climbed in my lap to see what was wrong.

News Flash from Breitbart: Phil Jones is stepping down as head of East Anglia’s CRU pending an investigation into leaked emails that reveal data collection was a continuing fraudulent effort and that there were ulterior motives involved in the Hoax that was perpetrated under East Anglia’s reputation.

The dominoes begin to fall.

The idea of climte modeling is silly on the face of it. The data we observe is not necessarily what the “earth” uses to operate. We don’t know much about how the weather functions, and even less about wht it takes to predict it. Just silly. Modeling is just a bunch of programmers involved in mental masturbation. We humans cannot even conceive of how this planet truly operates, how it formed, how we as a species will end, or how the earth will end. The governments of the world suck, we humans suck, and politicians, a special category of being. totally suck. I still don’t feel better after venting.

I wonder when the obsession with theoretical science will finally emasculate the general populations ability to see the Truth for what it is. The truth is always simple, which must be hard for someone persuing a deploma in the “arts” of scientific theology to accept. I hope it is not to late to recover our sense of sensibility.

The libs will fall back on their favorite line, the story is true even if all the facts can’t be verified. We know global warming is ‘real’ so damn the facts, full speed ahead to spending trillions of dollars and wrecking what’s left of american capitalism.

Can someone please get in touch with the hackers. We need them to hack the server at the Hawaiian DOH before the dump the original Birth Certificate. This is the only way we will get a look at the original.

Does the concept “relative truth” ring any bells. Our beautiful planet has been cyclical since before recorded history began. To move forward as a nation and a species, we cannot trust basic concepts of life to be redefined at hands of self obsorbed, “experts” who salivate at the mention of so called “issues” such as global warming. I remember reading my text books as a child and things of this nature were kept at bay using the termanology thresh-hold of suggestion. Now less than 2 decades later, they have been fabricated into HISTORICAL FACT??? The word CRAZY does have a definition found in our dictionary, and Lies still exist in our time.

My third grade teacher taught us about climate cycles. Her instruction has worked well for me all through this global warming/climate change debate. I have known that it was a fraud from the beginning. Thank you Mrs. McKinney!

That was 54 years ago.

The sky is falling, we are all going to die, my children will not know what a polar bear is. We must return to using candles for lights. No hot water usage or we are all going to die! Whats the matter with you nuts, can’t you see we destroying the earth, our breath alone is killing birds, snails fish etc.

Well, we can all breath a sigh of relief, bur while exhaling we need see the fraud that was occuring. This fraud is still in the government’s mind due to being the agenda of the sitting president. They want this falsehood to be a reality in order to destrou us all. He is till going to push this nonsence to the end. We have to figure a way to derail his upcomming trip. if he signs the treaty, we are all screwed. Can he be brought up on treason charges?

It is about time this is exposed for what it really is.

I think we should wait for Al Gore to weigh in on this. I’m sure we all have the utmost respect for the little weasel and will give his thoughts all the respect they merit. And Obama, that epitome of honesty and transparency will obviously want to face this issue head on in his usual manly fashion and deal with it in a speedy, yet thoughtful manner. Much as he did with the Afghan surge and his birth certificate. Then there’s the little matter of his college transcripts.
As the loonie Left’s core issues fade away, I wonder what they will come up with next. One thing is certain: they will never go away.

This is what to expect of the Left’s politicizing scientific investigations; as a result the ends become justification for the means and impartiality is gone from the process. Thease people would no doubt be willing to prove the Moon is made of green cheese as long as doing so fit their purpose.

Several months back I recall reading an article in Pravda where Russian scientitst were claiming all the global warming hype was just so much crap. The Russians claim Western science is flawed because the data does not extend over a sufficient period to be representative of any true trend, and in fact they think it’s more likely the world is headed for another Ice Age! Interesting isn’t it.

Al Gore was the only person that could save us from this disaster. If we had elected him the world would of been saved instead of destroyed by BUSH! Now we have the greatest President ever, and after he saves our country in the next 8 years, he will become the first World President. Obama has so much swaggart and class, and is the greatest President the US has ever know, and once the rest of the world see how great he will make the US, Obama will unite the world to one country and we will live in peace, harmony and forever be happy.. He will stop those big oil companies and make them pay for what they have done!

God help us all when the facts and the truth can be so redilly ignored and the fate of us all can be as easilly decided by the left, God bless Smith and Wesson, be ready Patriots

@Mikki?

Does your mommy know you’re on her computer, honey?

BURN!

Patvann ownage!

Mikki, what have you been smoking tonight?

Mikki,

By the way, have you seen the video “Not Evil Just Wrong” created by an Irish group focused on the nine major errors in Mr. Gore’s “An Inconvenient Truth”, about which he is reluctant to discuss?

Mr Gore also lives in a Mansion in the Nashville area which is said to consume more electric power on a typical evening than your local shopping mall, not to mention the private jet he uses to fly about the world! I wonder if they can recall a Nobel Prize?

Phillip:
Don’t worry: The president doesn’t have the right to sign the treaty before Cap ‘N Tax is passed by Congress.

Oops! I forgot: He doesn’t have to follow the rules. But don’t worry: Congress will refute it, if he signs without Cap ‘N Tax being passed.

Oops! I forgot: Congress is duty bound to do every single thing the president wants. But don’t worry: the American people will hold Congress to account in 2010.

Oops! I forgot: The American people were dumb enough to elect these people, in spite of all the signs of what kind of change we could expect.

Hmm. I’m worried too.

I always wondered why they would bother to build their carbon tax and trading schemes…

…only to then turn right around and kill off fossil fuels.

Why bother, right?

I think their plan all along was to milk out the age of oil, maximizing their profits. Just like the lyrics from the WHO song, We Won’t Get Fooled Again (damn near did too)…meet the New Boss, Same as the Old Boss…

In other words, either way, whether they get away with their fraud or not, oil is here to stay for a good time to come.

You can take that tip to the bank!

Even if he signs the treaty it takes 2/3 of the Senate to ratify it. The prospects for Cap and Tax are looking slimmer all the time.

The theme for the Congress elected in 2010 and 2012 needs to be REPEAL, REPEAL, REPEAL!

I guess the old adage applies: “You can fool some of the people some of the time, but you can’t fool all of the people all of the time.” Thank you dear Lord for common sense. But I know they will keep trying.

Note that they don’t really want to stop carbon emissions; they just want to tax it.

BTW: If they vote to repeal, the president can veto, so they need enough of a majority to override.

I think Mikki is just being sarcastic. It would take a world class fool to actually believe all that. Of course the Obamaton libs are world class fools so who knows.

@Ravgil: Yeah, I had noticed that they talk about reducing carbon emissions yet even the Kyoto signatories never do. They just tax it.

Doesn’t Al Gore still own stock in Occidental Petroleum? So he stands to benefit from the carbon credits scheme AND the increase of fuel costs.

What scares me is if Cap & Trade passes and the planet continues to cool, the libs will say it is due to our carbon reduction efforts. If the earth heats up, they will say we need tighter restrictions. They win either way! This is why we MUST kill this bs global warming HOAX. Tell all your friends about ClimateGate, write your local paper, write the media, write the politicians, e-blast it everywhere!! We have to cut thru years of indoctrination and emotional “nature guilt”. This HOAX is even more damaging to America than ObamaCare. The hacker is a HERO!!!

@Mike’sA

I live here just south of SanFran.

I’ve heard grown coworkers say the same sort of thing, then come to tears when I gently disagree.

Other people have challenged me to fights over him, and still others have actually called the cops because they thought I should be arrested for not being a fan of Obama. (and I now quote)

“Can you explain exactly what he said, because he says he never saw you before.”

“Someone should know the kind of things he’s saying about our president, so I called you”.

“But you said he was scaring you, and you felt threatened…He’s sitting there with his family.”

“Because I want you to make him stop”.

“We can’t do that ma’am. he has a right to say anything he wants to in a park. Have you tried walking away from his table?”

“But I heard him when I was walking by, and no one should hear that stuff in public.”

“Ma’am, I am citing you for making a false report, if you don’t leave the area right now.”

“I WANT YOUR BADGE NUMBER!”

The woman would not relent, things escalated, backup was called, and she was arrested.

I assure your Mike, the “belly of the beast” is not a pretty place. There is no bottom.

Can Rajendra Pachauri at least get a hair cut and a close shave before he tries to con me. Come on man, at least give me that!

Patvann –

That’s scary! At least the cop did the right thing. It would have really been scary if they took you in.

I have been to many tea parties. I cannot tell you how many times I have been called a racist and been flipped off. Some people really think he is the messiah.

If the US had both morals and balls, we would demand Rajadouche’s resignation for incompetence for making that sort of statement.

I’m thinking what we need is a good bumper sticker. Something simple yet poignant.

How about a bumper sticker with a single word…. “Obama” but replace the “O” with a Hammer and Sickle. I think that would say it all!

There will always be a human “worldly” problem, whether its about the forests, polar bears, climate change, etc., brought on by folks who have a severe guilt conscience and feel justified in blaming others for what they do not understand, or are unwilling to admit that THEY are wrong – scientists, politicians, media moguls, corrupt leaders…The fact of the matter is that the only thing that we humans should have learned is that nothing in Nature is static! Everything, from the majestic mountains of the Alps to the mighty Pacific Ocean, are in a state of change.
Spiff

@Spiff
That goes hand-in-hand with the axiom; If you believe in nothing, you will believe anything.

The human spirit longs to have a higher-power accompany it down the path of life. The higher power has many forms and even more names. When a person, or group of persons deny or reject that fact, they seek Truth elsewhere, even unconsciously. Those that know this, and seek power, use that replacement “Proxy-Truth” as a tool to gather the spiritually empty. As the numbers of those people increase, it begins to siphon off those who may be strong in spirit, but trusting in-heart/lacking in logic.

Logic coupled with Truth, is the most powerful force in the universe. The Left eats a way at logic by taking over the schools, and eats away at Truth by minimizing our need for the HigherPower.

All part of the plan. You see the result. Look at the Demographic of the AWG Believers, and how they have reacted to the hacking. We have put a crack into their Proxy-Truth, thus injuring their god…who has now been shown to be weak. Ed Begley’s reaction sums this up perfectly.

@Patvann: What’s the full story of that encounter you had with the woman who wanted you arrested?

I recall when Cindy Sheehan was in her hey day her gang was marching to protest and one of the kooks held a sign proclaiming “Fascism is on the march.” I doubt the fool would understand that it was SHE who was behaving like a fascist trying to shut down the free speech rights of others.

Meanwhile, what’s up with this post? 8,000 hits and counting!

Thank you folks. I was beginning to think that I was the only one on the
planet that felt the AGW claims were a hoax enhanced by media hype.

Re Al Gore: Having him lecture us on so-call global warming is similar to
him addressing an audience of neurosurgeons on the best techniques for
microsurgery on the brain.

I think this post is getting a lot of hits because Glenn Beck’s guest on Monday or Tuesday suggested we look up “Harry Read Me” for more info on the exposed hoax. That’s what brought me here… I am so JAZZED about this story and hope is continues to grow so we don’t destroy our economy and futures based on junk “science”. Finally I feel vindicated for believing what most of us have: that MMGW a fraud. FOX has a poll on its site. 80% say their minds have NOT been changed by ClimateGate, because they ALREADY KNEW IT WAS A HOAX!! We have been closeted too long. We need to speak up without fear. I’m going to find a bumper sticker that says “Man Made Global Warming is a HOAX” and see reaction.

@Mike

There was not much more than that.

Another family along with mine where simply having a good time at Lake Vasona park last summer, and the 4 adults were talking policies. We were not loud, but our bench was only about 10ft from the walking-path. Out of the blue this all started, and it was over in 5 minutes. The best part was the few people who commented to us afterword (in hushed tones).

The cop stuck around and made good conversation after she was packed up and shipped downtown for disruption, filing a false report, and resisting arrest. Never heard of her again.

Ya got a bunch of traffic from these folk:

http://www.bing.com/search?q=%22Climategate%E2%80%99s+%E2%80%9CHarry+Read+Me%E2%80%9D+File+is+a+Must+Read%21%22&src=IE-SearchBox&FORM=IE8SRC

-Curses! I’ll get you next time, Mr. America! 🙂

Meanwhile, over 11,000 views on this subject, and no real counter-posits!

@ Mods

ES from CA’s comment got me thinking. (No it didn’t hurt.)

We have a half dozen posts on this subject, all talking a concise view on the different angles of this hoax. What if we linked them in a common location on the front page, so that new visitors could read them all, and leave having been re-educated in the truth, plus feeling strong enough in their discovery to make the effort in spreading the word?

The posts all re-enforce each other, and the cause needs re-enforcing due to the non-coverage the MSM is trying to pull off.

@ES from Palm Springs, CA: Welcome. I hope you’ll stick around and read some of the other posts we have on this subject.

Interesting that you are from Palm Springs. It reminds me of when I was at EPA in the 90’s and a request came in for us to fund a group of Dept. of Agriculture bureaucrats to go to a meeting in Palm Springs on the subject of “Methane Emissions of Ruminant Livestock” to determine whether cows farting were contributing to global warming. I found it interesting that the meeting was in Palm Springs instead of somewhere more central to beef production.

Your tax dollars at play.

@Patvann: We could add a “climategate” category to the keywords. But that would mean I would have to remember to click the keyword for each post. And as Curt will tell you, I am notoriously bad at that.

Maybe we can do a post with short abstracts of each of the climategate posts. That might work. You want to do it?

1 2 3