Walker Gains in Wisconsin: NYT Shields Readers From Distressing News

By 2 Comments 432 views

The New York Times has a long piece on the political situation in Wisconsin this morning, and in some ways it is reasonably balanced. The reporters note, for example, that the Koch brothers own a factory in Wisconsin that is unionized and that the union and management at the factory seem to have a reasonably productive relationship. It also gives controversial Governor Scott Walker some space to contest the arguments of his detractors.

Even so, it is a journalistic disaster: it tells you everything you need to know except the one thing you really need to know, and it reveals the soft pale underbelly of establishment journalism in America today.

The headline captures the focus of the piece: “Recall Election Tests Strategies For November.” The reporters look at how private and public sector unions on the one side and various conservative organizations on the other are organizing for the election over the petition to recall Governor Scott Walker and at how both sides think the issues and strategies shaping the recall will influence the outcome in November.

The piece does a reasonable job at getting the views of both sides, but no reader of the Times will be surprised to see that it wears its heart on its sleeve. The piece closes with a paean to the hope that labor will beat back the Republican challenge, calculated to warm the hearts of the NYT faithful:

However, labor leaders say the moves have reinvigorated members, prompting a beefing up of political operations. This contributed to the repeal, in a referendum last year, of an Ohio law limiting bargaining rights, has fueled the recall effort in Wisconsin, and, unions hope, will lead to Democratic success in November.

Nearly all of the larger confrontations have taken place in presidential battlegrounds, not only Wisconsin and Ohio, but also states like Florida, Michigan and New Hampshire.

“These state fights are a jump-start to get people engaged,” said Brandon Davis, political director for theService Employees International Union. “We’re confident that if we get turnout to vote in municipal elections, they will also vote our way in national elections.”

Bob Kelley, a retired union carpenter, agreed as he hammered together a partition for a new call center in Madison. “If you’re where somebody throws down a gauntlet and attacks, what are you going to do?” he said, referring to Mr. Walker. “Maybe he did us a favor.”

Perhaps Bob Kelley is right, and Governor Walker did the unions a favor; Via Meadia has suggested that in both Wisconsin and Ohio a more narrowly focused, better thought through, less confrontational approach could have made the necessary reforms with a lot less trouble and polarization.

But somehow the reporters and editors who put together this long story on the implications of the Wisconsin recall for American politics now and in November failed to take note of one tiny little fact: Governor Walker is increasingly favored to win the June recalll.

Intrade, a site where people can in effect bet on political races, shows Walker with a 68.5 percent chance of re-election as of Sunday morning. (By contrast, President Obama has only a 59.7 percent shot at a second term.) Recent polls on the race show Walker ahead, though the race is close and volatile — and the dynamics may change once the Democrats pick a nominee. None of this appears in this article.

Forget accusations of media bias and ideological agendas: this is a collapse of basic news judgment. On this issue at least, readers who rely on the New York Times to tell them what’s happening in the country — don’t know what’s happening in the country. They genuinely don’t know that in Wisconsin this all out mobilization by both sides on a polarizing question is, tentatively and certainly not irreversibly, but noticeably and to a certain degree increasingly… breaking Walker’s way.

Read more

Filed under Uncategorized

Curt served in the Marine Corps for four years and has been a law enforcement officer in Los Angeles for the last 24 years.

2 Responses to “Walker Gains in Wisconsin: NYT Shields Readers From Distressing News”

  1. 1


    I recently returned from a week in northern WI. Being my mild mannered self, I started my conversations in gas stations and restaurants with “here sure are a lot of empty houses and businesses here” Why would you folks elect a Governor to balance the budget and then when he does without raising taxes do you recall him?” I got a lot of heated replies. Most people described the issue as those bastards in Madison and Milwaukee have their head up their _ss.

    I think there is much more support for Walker than the polls show. People are angry at the unions and they are motivated to vote! One lady just got a job in MI where she was getting a pay raise to $30K. Things in Northern WI must be really bad for people to move to MI.

  2. 2

    Nan G

    Despite Wisconsin’s unemployment rate being well below the national rate and steadily falling, on Saturday’s NBC Nightly News correspondent Ron Allen selectively hyped job losses.
    The Federal Bureau of Labor Statistics says Wisconsin lost 23,900 jobs between March 2011 and March 2012.
    That same Bureau of Labor Statistics report showed that Wisconsin’s unemployment rate fell from 7.6% to 6.8% in that same time period.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *