10
Sep

Petraeus REPORTS!

Posted by: Mike's America @ 1:37 pm in The Iraqi War  | 0 views

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

As the Sun rose this Monday morning, a momentary hush settled over the Capital. General Petraeus was in town and he came to report on Iraq. His first stop, the House Armed Services Committee.

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at PhotobucketPhoto Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

As the General made his way through the Halls of Congress the loony left was out in force, doing what they do best: behaving like spoiled children and dressed as if they were headed to a Halloween party.

As the General spoke, the circus show briefly disrupted his remarks. Apparently they feel their right to be heard trumps the American people’s right to be informed. They were expelled from the hearing.

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

What message where the circus clowns above so desperate to block? Here it is. The Petraeus Report (text in pdf, slides in pdf)

Report to Congress on the Situation in Iraq

General David H. Petraeus

Commander, Multi-National Force-Iraq

10-11 September 2007

General Petraeus: "At the outset, I would like to note that this is my testimony. Although I have briefed my assessment and recommendations to my chain of command, I wrote this testimony myself. It has not been cleared by, nor shared with, anyone in the Pentagon, the White House, or Congress.

We endeavor to ensure our analysis of that data is conducted with rigor and consistency, as our ability to achieve a nuanced understanding of the security environment is dependent on collecting and analyzing data in a consistent way over time. Two US intelligence agencies recently reviewed our methodology, and they concluded that the data we produce is the most accurate and authoritative in Iraq. "

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

"Coalition and Iraqi operations have helped reduce ethno-sectarian violence, as well, bringing down the number of ethno-sectarian deaths substantially in Baghdad and across Iraq since the height of the sectarian violence last December. The number of overall civilian deaths has also declined during this period, although the numbers in each area are still at troubling levels."

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

"Though the improvements have been uneven across Iraq, the overall number of security incidents in Iraq has declined in 8 of the past 12 weeks, with the numbers of incidents in the last two weeks at the lowest levels seen since June 2006. One reason for the decline in incidents is that Coalition and Iraqi forces have dealt significant blows to Al Qaeda-Iraq.

In the past six months we have also targeted Shia militia extremists, capturing a number of senior leaders and fighters, as well as the deputy commander of Lebanese Hezbollah Department 2800, the organization created to support the training, arming, funding, and, in some cases, direction of the militia extremists by the Iranian Republican Guard Corps’ Qods Force. These elements have assassinated and kidnapped Iraqi governmental leaders, killed and wounded our soldiers with advanced explosive devices provided by Iran, and indiscriminately rocketed civilians in the International Zone and elsewhere. It is increasingly apparent to both Coalition and Iraqi leaders that Iran, through the use of the Qods Force, seeks to turn the Iraqi Special Groups into a Hezbollah-like force to serve its interests and fight a proxy war against the Iraqi state and coalition forces in Iraq."

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

"In view of this, I do not believe it is reasonable to have an adequate appreciation for the pace of further reductions and mission adjustments beyond the summer of 2008 until about mid-March of next year. We will, no later than that time, consider factors similar to those on which I based the current recommendations, having by then, of course, a better feel for the security situation, the improvements in the capabilities of our Iraqi counterparts, and the enemy situation. I will then, as I did in developing the recommendations I have explained here today, also take into consideration the demands on our Nation’s ground forces, although I believe that that consideration should once again inform, not drive, the recommendations I make.

This chart captures the recommendations I have described, showing the recommended reduction of brigade combat teams as the surge runs its course and illustrating the concept of our units adjusting their missions and transitioning responsibilities to Iraqis, as the situation and Iraqi capabilities permit. It also reflects the no-later-than date for recommendations on force adjustments beyond next summer and provides a possible approach we have considered for the future force structure and mission set in Iraq.

Before closing, I want to thank you and your colleagues for your support of our men and women in uniform in Iraq. The Soldiers, Sailors, Airmen, Marines, and Coast Guardsmen with whom I’m honored to serve are the best equipped and, very likely, the most professional force in our nation’s history. Impressively, despite all that has been asked of them in recent years, they continue to raise their right hands and volunteer to stay in uniform. With three weeks to go in this fiscal year, in fact, the Army elements in Iraq, for example, have achieved well over 130% of the reenlistment goals in the initial term and careerist categories and nearly 115% in the mid-career category. All of us appreciate what you have done to ensure that these great troopers have had what they’ve needed to accomplish their mission, just as we appreciate what you have done to take care of their families, as they, too, have made significant sacrifices in recent years.

In closing, it remains an enormous privilege to soldier again in Iraq with America’s new “Greatest Generation.” Our country’s men and women in uniform have done a magnificent job in the most complex and challenging environment imaginable. All Americans should be very proud of their sons and daughters serving in Iraq today."

Brit Hume of Fox News will interview both General Petraeus and U.S. Ambassador to Iraq Ryan Crocker, who also testified, tonight at 9 PM est.

  • Share/Bookmark
Print This Post Print This Post
This entry was posted on Monday, September 10th, 2007 at 1:37 pm and is filed under The Iraqi War. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

Trackbacks

7 comments so far

scrapiron
 1Reply to this comment  

The dimorats sure know how to put the ‘Dim’ before the rat. Todays congressional hearing is worse than a poorly directed circus. Listening to these dimocrats should make America puke. It starts with an accidential??? mike problem and continues with interuptions by the idiots from code pink. What a dozen massive overweight ugly women? I guess in the circus they would be the baboons sticking they’re fingers up their butt and licking it off. Maybe the democrats just have their Chinese bagman ‘Hsu’ on the wrong foot. and it hurts.

September 10th, 2007 at 3:29 pm
David
 2Reply to this comment  

Unfortunately, today’s hearing went as expected … a three-ring circus, with more rings added for effect. And, of course, as always, the MSM only wanted to “report” what it wanted to report.

The best part – the Dems being bitterly disappointed that significant progress is being made.

September 10th, 2007 at 7:43 pm
thebronze
 3Reply to this comment  

DemocRats are traitors.

September 10th, 2007 at 11:49 pm
David
 4Reply to this comment  

Former Speaker Newt Gingrich, in a copy of a prepared speech at the American Enterprise Institute, said the Petraeus Report is “wholly inadequate.”

The article referencing Gingrich’s remarks may be found here: http://www.newsmax.com/insidecover/Gingrich_Iraq/2007/09/11/31693.html.

If the report is “wholly inadequate,” what does the former speaker want? By winning the Iraq war, AQ loses. Also, Hamas and Hezbollah will begin to lose their influence and that of their state sponsor, Iran.

Gingrich is engaging in the same kind of second guessing from the sidelines.

September 11th, 2007 at 3:38 pm
markustee
 5Reply to this comment  

I was pleased to read the positive things in the General’s report. They were as was expected, of course; there is no way in today’s media rich environment to pull off any surprises in a report like this. His report was encouraging, and anyone that says otherwise is not truly an American.

Logically, however, one must define first was is “progress”, what is “good”, and what is “improvement”. In my view, and I don’t think I am alone, all three of these terms must be defined in terms of developing a stable government in Iraq that is actively opposed to the activity of terrorism, regardless of its source.

The purpose of the military involvement is to provide a measure of stability for that government to form. They have done so admirably, and for that, we have what can be counted no less than a superb military success. However, the other part of the equation is the development of that government, which requires an even greater effort and desire on the part of the Iraqi leaders and people. That effort, by the Iraqis, has failed utterly. We must therefore examine the Iraqi resolve to form that government. What I am seeing is leadership consisting of a corrupt gaggle of political geese, eager to line their own pockets, and anxious for the United States to give them more time to do so. I do not see the spirit of patriotism in Iraq that compares to that in the United States prior to 1776, and as is required to form such a government. While there are some Iraqis that desire freedom, there are not enough. Most Iraqis still believe it is OK – even good – to kill Americans.

In view of that, our objective cannot succeed, and it is not in our power or control to make it do so. Therefore, we must leave Iraq to the natural consequences of their own cowardice. This is politically a terrible alternative, although any other alternative is worse. We need to come to grips with the fact that Iraq, when we leave, will fall to Iran or other fascist and terroristic groups, unless the Iraqis can find a leader of their own people to galvanize Iraq to defend itself. If no leader is found, when we leave, we must be ready to defend ourselves against that terrorism, which will probably mean destruction of innocent Iraqis en masse.

It is a horrible dilemma, but destruction is the price of cowardice. The United States -which is defined by its citizens – does not wish to be an Imperial nation, governing the earth. In truth, our fathers left European and Asian soil to build a free nation because there was no place in the old world that such a nation could be built. Cowardice stayed in place, and while it is still there, no freedom can exist for long. We watch Europe totter on the brink of socialism and disaster, while the extreme left tries to do the same to our nation. Our domestic enemies are as dangerous as our foreign ones.

General Petreus, I salute your valiant effort in the cause of defending freedom. Military men and women, I salute you as well, with great gratitude for your sacrifice, dedication, and patriotism. President Bush, you have attempted a great feat, but the Iraqis have left you without recourse. I salute your desire, but you must look at this realistically, and soon. Please do not leave it to your successor.

To the next President and Congress – you must be up to the task. We will have to leave, whether sooner or later, and it appears that President Bush will not see it soon enough to spare you the burden of making this decision. Sooner will mean more Iraqi deaths. Later will mean more American deaths. The scale is not equal, many times as many Iraqis will die as Americans in either case. Remember that you are the American government, and your responsibility is to the American people, not to the world. The political toll will be tremendous – for many will die, and those who consider themselves citizens of the world rather than Americans will hate you, and they are many in this nation. You cannot prevent that. Your task is formidable, and near history will not see you favorably in either case. You must look far into the future for your vindication. You will be vindicated only if America and freedom survive. If tyranny becomes our way of life, you will be hated if you do what is right, and sainted by the tyrants for succumbing to cowardice. Remember who will judge you, and take courage. This life is short.

To the American people – we must become a fierce and feared people to survive. We must become feared far and wide. We must not submit to the tyranny of socialism or the tyranny of Islam. Our freedom is at stake. Those that would deceive you into thinking that we can trust government to take care of us would rob you of your freedom. Look for a leader that will be courageous and demand the same of you, that would depend on you to stand on your own two feet, to look the enemy in the eye, and to defeat the enemy where you stand. We have no demigods to lead us, only men – weak, fallible, and easily killed, but some have courage. There is only one God, trust in Him, and stand courageously behind a courageous leader. America, to remain America the Beautiful, home of the Free and land of the Brave, will in all likelihood have to become America the Terrible to the rest of the world – for freedom is not without cost. Slavery is free; Freedom is costly.

September 11th, 2007 at 10:10 pm
markustee
 6Reply to this comment  

I was pleased to read the positive things in General Petreus’ report. They were as was expected, of course; there is no way in today’s media rich environment to pull off any surprises in a report like this. His report was encouraging, and anyone that says otherwise is not truly an American.

Logically, however, one must define first was is “progress”, what is “good”, and what is “improvement”. In my view, and I don’t think I am alone, all three of these terms must be defined in terms of developing a stable government in Iraq that is actively opposed to the activity of terrorism, regardless of its source.

The purpose of the military involvement is to provide a measure of stability for that government to form. They have done so admirably, and for that, we have what can be counted no less than a superb military success. However, the other part of the equation is the development of that government, which requires an even greater effort and desire on the part of the Iraqi leaders and people. That effort, by the Iraqis, has failed utterly. We must therefore examine the Iraqi resolve to form that government. What I am seeing is leadership consisting of a corrupt gaggle of political geese, eager to line their own pockets, and anxious for the United States to give them more time to do so. I do not see the spirit of patriotism in Iraq that compares to that in the United States prior to 1776, and as is required to form such a government. While there are some Iraqis that desire freedom, there are not enough. Most Iraqis still believe it is OK – even good – to kill Americans.

In view of that, our objective cannot succeed, and it is not in our power or control to make it do so. Therefore, we must leave Iraq to the natural consequences of their own cowardice. This is politically a terrible alternative, although any other alternative is worse. We need to come to grips with the fact that Iraq, when we leave, will fall to Iran or other fascist and terroristic groups, unless the Iraqis can find a leader of their own people to galvanize Iraq to defend itself. If no leader is found, when we leave, we must be ready to defend ourselves against that terrorism, which will probably mean destruction of innocent Iraqis en masse.

It is a horrible dilemma, but destruction is the price of cowardice. The United States -which is defined by its citizens – does not wish to be an Imperial nation, governing the earth. In truth, our fathers left European and Asian soil to build a free nation because there was no place in the old world that such a nation could be built. Cowardice stayed in place, and while it is still there, no freedom can exist for long. We watch Europe totter on the brink of socialism and disaster, while the extreme left tries to do the same to our nation. Our domestic enemies are as dangerous as our foreign ones.

General Petreus, I salute your valiant effort in the cause of defending freedom. Military men and women, I salute you as well, with great gratitude for your sacrifice, dedication, and patriotism. President Bush, you have attempted a great feat, but the Iraqis have left you without recourse. I salute your desire, but you must look at this realistically, and soon. Please do not leave it to your successor.

To the next President and Congress – you must be up to the task. We will have to leave, whether sooner or later, and it appears that President Bush will not see it soon enough to spare you the burden of making this decision. Sooner will mean more Iraqi deaths. Later will mean more American deaths. The scale is not equal, many times as many Iraqis will die as Americans in either case. Remember that you are the American government, and your responsibility is to the American people, not to the world. The political toll will be tremendous – for many will die, and those who consider themselves citizens of the world rather than Americans will hate you, and they are many in this nation. You cannot prevent that. Your task is formidable, and near history will not see you favorably in either case. You must look far into the future for your vindication. You will be vindicated only if America and freedom survive. If tyranny becomes our way of life, you will be hated if you do what is right, and sainted by the tyrants for succumbing to cowardice. Remember who will judge you, and take courage. This life is short.

To the American people – we must become a fierce and feared people to survive. We must become feared far and wide. We must not submit to the tyranny of socialism or the tyranny of Islam. Our freedom is at stake. Those that would deceive you into thinking that we can trust government to take care of us would rob you of your freedom. Look for a leader that will be courageous and demand the same of you, that would depend on you to stand on your own two feet, to look the enemy in the eye, and to defeat the enemy where you stand. We have no demigods to lead us, only men – weak, fallible, and easily killed, but some have courage. There is only one God, trust in Him, and stand courageously behind a courageous leader. America, to remain America the Beautiful, home of the Free and land of the Brave, will in all likelihood have to become America the Terrible to the rest of the world – for freedom is not without cost. Slavery is free; Freedom is costly.

September 11th, 2007 at 10:20 pm
 7Reply to this comment  

Good grief! All those words when what you really said was “get out of Iraq now and damn the consequences.”

As I have pointed out to countless others, no great goal is easily achieveable and few small goals matter much.

You point to the patriotic fervor of our own Revolutionary period but perhaps fail to realize that more than half the country was either opposed or indifferent to independence. And it took decades to establish a proper governing framework. Even then there was that little matter of a Civil War 80 years into our experiment in democracy.

It boggles my mind that somehow we should expect more from the Iraqis than the pace of our own history.

Markustee: You spent a great many words erecting a rhetorical edifice upon flawed premises. I suggest you rethink your viewpoint within the context of history and PLEASE try and keep it brief!

September 11th, 2007 at 11:15 pm

Leave a reply

Name (*)
Mail (will not be published) (*)
URI
Comment

If your comments get caught in spam a lot please log into your registered account before trying to comment again. You can email me if your comment is caught in spam

 

Identity Verification: If you wish to verify your commenter identity, so no one can steal it, click the below button: